No media available

Reference

Job 3:1-5, 7-10; 4:1-6; Job 4:7-9, 17, 19-21  
Rev. Karen's Reflection for October 4th, 2026
Ben Kupke – Unsplash

Karen Hollis | Oct 4, 2026  xth Sunday after Pentecost 

 Intro to Job: 

As you may remember, the book of Job is kind of a poetry sandwich. The beginning and end of the book are prose and in the middle are 39 chapters of some of the most exquisite poetry ever composed. It turns out that the beginning and ending is a folktale that was well known in the near east as early as 2000 BCE, and it appears that the Job poet used the tale for the setting of their poetic work.  

Our scripture readings are going to jump into the text in the place where the poetry starts, so I’m going to give you a quick synopsis of the setting. The tale begins essentially: Once upon a time in the land of Uz, there was a man named Job. It’s a folktale, set in a place called “counsel,” a place of discussion. We’re introduced to Job, the archetype of a good person. He is blessed with family, land, animals, employees, he is a good neighbour and has status in his community.  

Then the story takes us to God, or an anthropomorphized version thereof, who has gathered the members of the heavenly court. Among them is HaSatan, who has just come from roaming about in the world. HaSatan has often been translated Satan, but it actually means “the Adversary.” It is not a proper name, rather a role among many in the divine court.  

God asks HaSatan if he has seen Job, the most faithful one. HaSatan says “yes, of course, but I wonder if Job is so faithful because he’s been protected on all sides from any kind of suffering. I wonder if Job will curse God if the things in his life are taken away and he suffers in his body.” God gives permission for HaSatan to make it so and see how Job responds.  

As calamity after calamity is reported to Job, followed by his skin breaking out with boils and things . . . while he is deeply grieved and disturbed, Job never blames God. In fact, after his wife tells him to curse God, he replies to her: “only foolish people talk like that. If we accept happiness from God, we should also accept adversity.”  

Job’s friends hear of Job’s misfortune and come to visit him . . . and this is where the poetry begins . . . but the Job poet doesn’t agree with the folktale. The poet picks up the story and says, I’m not so sure that humans are so accepting of our suffering. Perhaps there is more going on within us than this character lets on, and the Job poet proceeds to gift us with 39 chapters of delicious poetry, of dialogue, of exploration . . . their poetry creates a container where we are invited to wonder . . . wonder about the eternal question of suffering, about what happens when we encounter things that our worldview can’t explain, about our impact on the world beyond what we can see, where God is in all of this, and much more. Let’s dive in. 

 

First Reading: Job 3:1-5, 7-10; 4:1-6 (for intro to the text: Job speaks for the first time) 

Afterward, Job opened his mouth and cursed his day. And Job spoke up and he said: 

Annul the day that I was born 

and the night that said, “A man is conceived.” 

That day, let it be darkness. 

Let God above not seek it out, 

nor brightness shine upon it. 

Let darkness, death’s shadow, foul it, 

Let a cloud-mass rest upon it, 

let day-gloom dismay it. 

Oh, let that night be barren, 

let it have no song of joy. 

Let the day-cursers hex it, 

those ready to rouse Leviathan. 

Let its twilight stars go dark. 

Let it hope for day in vain, 

and let it not see the eyelids of dawn. 

For it did not shut the belly’s doors 

to hide wretchedness from my eyes. 

 

Job 4:7-9, 17, 19-21  

Recall, pray: what innocent man has died, 

and where were the upright demolished? 

As I have seen, those who plow mischief, 

those who plant wretchedness, reap it. 

Through God’s breath they die, 

before his nostrils’ breathing they vanish. 

Can a mortal be cleared before God, 

can a man be made pure by his Maker? 

All the more so, the clay-house dwellers, 

whose foundation is in the dust, 

who are crushed more quickly than moths. 

From morning to eve they are shattered, 

unawares they are lost forever. 

Should their life thread be broken within them, 

they die, and without any wisdom. 

 Let us pray . . . May the words of my mouth and the meditations of all our hearts be reflections of your word to us today, in Christ’s name we pray. Amen 

 Like many of you, there was a time when I found Job really daunting. Suffering is of course a real part of the human experience and we don’t want to push it away entirely, but this book can be a real bummer to read. And then I discovered Robert Alter’s translation and fell in love with the poetry. Alter is a master Hebrew scholar who takes extra care to honour the Hebrew words and the rhythm of the language as he expresses them in English. He explains that the genre of biblical poetry uses a series of intensifications of language to engage the reader or hearer. For instance, the poem begins with Job saying: annul the day that I was born. With that simple statement we learn that fundamentally, he wishes not for his suffering to stop, but to never have been born . . . that’s clear enough, but the poet continues to unpack and intensify this idea: “That day, let it be darkness. Let God above not seek it out, nor brightness shine upon it. Oh, let that night be barren, let it have no song of joy. Let its twilight stars go dark. Let it hope for day in vain, and let it not see the eyelids of dawn.” Robert Alter comments on the enormous vocabulary the Job poet draws on to compose this work. They use image after image to invite us into Job’s experience, as bleak as it may be.  

In his time of suffering, Job’s friends offer him an extraordinary kindness. The text says: “they sat with him on the ground seven days and seven nights, and none spoke a word to him, for they saw that the pain was very great.” When someone we know is suffering, it’s difficult to know what to do, how to respond, what to say. And we hear time and again, just be there, just be present. Give them the gift of your presence, your energy. And that’s what his friends did. And after 7 days, Job speaks this longing to annul his birth, his friends respond, and a dialogue between them unfolds, as they wonder together why this is happening to Job.  

Eliphaz shares first the common Jewish theology of the day. He invites them to recall, if they can, an innocent man who has died. “Where were the upright demolished? 

As I have seen, those who plow mischief, those who plant wretchedness, reap it. Through God’s breath they die, before his nostrils’ breathing they vanish. From morning to eve they are shattered, unawares they are lost forever. Should their life thread be broken within them, they die, and without any wisdom.”  

The poetry births image after image, as Eliphas wonders aloud: Job, what did you do to bring this on? You must have done something. The upright don’t just suffer for no reason. As the dialogue unfolds, the Job poet brings voice after voice into the mix, unpacking bit by bit this traditional theology of cause and effect, creating this vast container for Job and us to reflect and wonder if real life isn’t much more complex than this.  

In the midst of it all, Job finds himself reflecting on a time when life was simpler, when the world around him made sense. He says: 

Would that I were as in moons of yore, 

        as the days when God watched over me, 

when Shaddai still was with me, (Shaddai is a Hebrew name for God) 

all around me my lads; 

when my feet bathed in curds 

and the rock poured out streams of oil 

when I went out to the city’s gate, 

in the square I secured my seat. 

Lads saw me and took cover, 

the aged arose, stood up. 

(the images are intensifying) 

Noblemen held back their words, 

their palm they put to their mouth. 

The voice of the princes was muffled, 

their tongue to their palate stuck. 

When the ear heard, it affirmed me, 

and the eye saw and acclaimed me. 

For I would free the poor who cried out, 

the orphan with no one to help him. 

 Job was at the center of his world, people deferred to him, looked up to him, and reached out to him for help. But it seems that’s all he could see, the world that was centered around him . . . and then this awful thing happens to him and his understanding of the world is inadequate to help him make sense of what is unfolding. He longs for his safely packaged life, where the chaos of the world was well managed . . . but God invites him to see more.  

I think about the beginning of the COVID pandemic, where we were checking the news to see where the virus was spreading, where infections were bad. We listening to our Provincial Health Minister, Bonnie Henry, tell us to be kind, be calm, and be safe. And we needed to hear it, because as a collective, we didn’t know what was happening or where it would lead. We were worried and afraid . . . and grieving people and the world we knew. That time also gave us a sacred pause to see our world from a little different perspective, to expand our view, and see in ways we never had before how connected we all are. We reached out to one another, we stuck together, we turned to God for comfort amid the chaos.  

But to go through the deconstruction of our worldview without a sense of God’s presence can be especially scary. And that is the most difficult part for Job. For most of the conversation with his friends, Job experiences God as silent. He longs to hear from God, longs to feel that comfort and that presence, to know that God is present in the struggle. While I think God is present regardless of our ability to sense their presence, I wonder if this kind of wrestling with our circumstances is sometimes an essential part of the process. . . perhaps it is that very wrestling that then allows us to hear God speaking in new ways. 

Expanding our container is not comfortable or easy – we’ve all been there – the only path is through . . . to the gift that can be found on the other side. And the gift for Job is enormous. We’ll begin unpacking that gift next week.